The comparison between integrated and separated electrical assist and shifting systems in three-speed transmission

The comparison between integrated and separated electrical assist and shifting systems in a three-speed transmission setup can be explained in the following aspects:

1. System Structure:

   • Integrated System: The electrical assist and shifting are combined, typically with the motor directly connected to the transmission. The electric assist not only provides power support but also works in coordination with the gear system through sensors and electronic controls to adjust both the assist level and the gears. This design allows for more precise control of the power output, providing a smoother riding experience.
   • Separated System: The electric assist and shifting systems are independent. The electric assist provides power, while the gear system handles shifting. They work through separate control modules, where the electric assist adjusts based on rider input or sensor feedback, while the gear system is adjusted manually or electronically without automatic coordination with the assist.
   • CROSS YOUR CITY, ADO EBIKE.
   • 

2. Control Method:

   • Integrated System: Usually equipped with a smart control system, where a central processing unit (e.g., electronic control unit) integrates both the electric assist and gear shifting. It automatically adjusts the assist power and gear based on factors such as speed, cadence, and rider input, creating a seamless transition between assist and gears.
   • Separated System: The electric assist and gears are controlled independently by the rider. The assist adjusts based on the rider’s preferences or input, while gear shifting is entirely up to the rider. The system may have less intelligence in terms of coordination, requiring more manual input from the rider.

3. Riding Experience:

   • Integrated System: The experience is smoother and more seamless as the assist and shifting are coordinated automatically. This allows riders to focus more on riding without having to frequently adjust gears, making it especially user-friendly for beginners or urban commuting.
   • Separated System: The experience is more traditional, with the rider needing to manually shift gears. While it gives the rider more control over gear selection and power output, the transition between assist and shifting may feel less smooth, especially in changing terrain.

4. Maintenance and Adjustment:

   • Integrated System: These systems are more complex and may require specialized maintenance, especially if there is an issue with the electrical components or the integrated control system. Technicians may need higher expertise to service the bike.
   • Separated System: The electric assist and transmission are independent, making it easier to maintain and repair. If one system malfunctions, it can be addressed separately without affecting the other system, which can be more convenient and less costly for repairs.

5. Cost:

   • Integrated System: Due to the complexity of integrating both assist and shifting systems, bikes with this setup are generally more expensive. The production and maintenance costs are higher due to the sophisticated technology involved.
   • Separated System: These systems tend to be more affordable, as the assist and shifting components are separate, and the overall design is simpler. Manufacturing and repair costs are lower compared to integrated systems.

In summary, an integrated system offers a more intelligent and smoother experience, with automatic coordination between assist and shifting, but comes at a higher price and with more complex maintenance. A separated system provides more manual control and is generally less expensive but may require more rider input for gear shifting and adjusting power levels.

CROSS YOUR CITY, ADO EBIKE!